Skip to content

Combining decision methods

Some questions cannot be answered in one go. Rhizome offers two ways of dealing with this: four built-in processes that kick in automatically, and the free combination of several decisions within a single topic.

What happens naturally

Four processes are hard-wired. You don’t need to start them – they arise from what someone does.

Starting point Trigger What follows
Consent someone proposes an Alternative A vote on opposition between the two proposals, the winner of which becomes the new consensus
Consensus the same a vote to gauge opposition, the winner of which becomes the consensus once more
Consultation nomination round as a means of selecting the decider Consent regarding the proposed person, followed by the actual consultation
Role-based the same Consent regarding the person, followed by the actual decision

Each of these steps begins as a draft. Rhizome creates it, but does not launch it – there is always a moment in between when you can talk.

The issue does not move on. A thread may go through several decisions without the issue being considered resolved; you decide this manually.

What you put together yourselves

Furthermore, within a single topic, several decisions may run concurrently. This is the actual possibility of combination – not one mode merging into the next, but a second question alongside the first.

The pulse check is the most useful tool here: a decision that isn’t binding, but simply shows where you stand. Afterwards, you make a binding decision based on what you now know.

Examples

  • Sort first, then decide: A ranking as a pulse check puts the twelve proposals in order. You then make a binding decision on the top three via a majority vote.
  • Gauge opposition, then formulate: A resistance poll as a gauge of pulse check shows where the concerns lie. The proposal with the least opposition is revised and then moves on to the consent.
  • Quickly gauge the general trend: A majority vote serves as a pulse check, clarifying within an hour whether the effort involved in a dot poll is even worthwhile.

You can carry over proposals

You don’t need to type anything between two decisions. A Remix] starts the next decision with the proposals from the previous one, and proposals collected in the thread are available to choose from when creating a new one anyway.